Examples: boulevard rather than wide, tree-lined street; sting rather than painful bite (n.); bee-stung (as a verb) rather than bitten by an insect; slither through, rather than move stealthily through the crowd, etc.
Like all rules, the adjective/adverb rule needs to be taken with a grain of salt. Of course great writers use adjectives and adverbs. Hemingway, noted for his short, direct sentences, did use modifiers, especially adjectives—plenty of them.
But most important is clarity. To paraphrase E.B. White, the closest a writer can get to Godliness is Clarity.
Then, if you want to add a few halos, you need to make sure your writing has not only clarity, but depth. The key to clarity and depth: word specificity, as indicated above in Long's definition of 'concrete' words.
But most important is clarity. To paraphrase E.B. White, the closest a writer can get to Godliness is Clarity.
Then, if you want to add a few halos, you need to make sure your writing has not only clarity, but depth. The key to clarity and depth: word specificity, as indicated above in Long's definition of 'concrete' words.
Select your words with clarity in mind, and make sure they mean exactly what you're trying to convey. This is not as easy as it sounds. To avoid superficiality or lack of nuance, you need to dig deep into your vocabulary bag and find words that are clear and specific, but not necessarily simple. There's no shame in using a thesaurus to find the right word.
An example from Pricilla Long, quoting writer Tim O'Brien on how to describe what war is like for soldiers:
There are modifiers in O'Brien's descriptive language (powdery, orange-red), but note how they flow from the tongue in a powerful rhythm as if emerging from the concrete descriptors that came before them.
Writing a strong sentence with concrete, specific nouns and verbs is a great exercise for all of us to do every day until it's what comes naturally. Do you have one you'd be willing to share?
An example from Pricilla Long, quoting writer Tim O'Brien on how to describe what war is like for soldiers:
- First, Long's example of abstract (cannot be perceived through the senses) descriptive language: "War is burdensome on soldiers." 'Burdensome' does little to let the reader sense what war is like for soldiers.
- Tim O'Brien's concrete, specific language (visual, smelly, and itchy): "They carried diseases, among them malaria and dysentery. They carried lice and ringworm and leeches and paddy algae and various rots and molds. They carried the land itself—Viet Nam, the place, the soil—a powdery orange-red dust that covered their boots and fatigues and faces. ....."
There are modifiers in O'Brien's descriptive language (powdery, orange-red), but note how they flow from the tongue in a powerful rhythm as if emerging from the concrete descriptors that came before them.
Writing a strong sentence with concrete, specific nouns and verbs is a great exercise for all of us to do every day until it's what comes naturally. Do you have one you'd be willing to share?
Excellent post. In my writing I struggle with using concrete verbs and I tend to go naturally for the passive choice. This helps.
ReplyDeleteSo glad it was useful, Denise. It's so natural to most of us to assume that only some writers have this skill, which is simply not true. We all can.
DeleteThis post really struck me. I totally learned something new today. THANK YOU!!!!
ReplyDeleteYou're so welcome, Laura. Priscilla Long is amazing in her ability to identify what makes writing go from average to excellent.
DeleteFantastic post. I just spent a day deleting extra adverbs and adjectives from one of my authors books. She'll appreciate me for it when she re-reads and accepts that stronger verbs and nouns are the difference between good and great!
ReplyDeleteShe WILL appreciate you for it, Rachel. Thanks for dropping by!
DeleteLinda, this is fabulous. I'm really finding your posts something I want to print. So my friend, when you get enough of these. we're going to make you an ebook, and put it on the market. We will definitely need to have a party to brainstorm the idea.
ReplyDeleteIs "The Writer's Portable Mentor by Priscilla Long" a book I need to add to my writing shelf?
Thank you for this. I will help my writing tremendously.
Thanks so much,Karlene. I love that idea--especially the brainstorming part. Red or white wine??
DeleteYes, your writing shelf wants a copy of The Writer's Portable Mentor!
Great points! Strong writing equals a powerful read that will keep the reader coming back for more. I used to write very adverb and adjective heavy based off books I read when I was young. I'm thrilled to say that I've advanced along with the industry, though it certainly wasn't a painless process. ;)
ReplyDeleteYes, some of those YA writers of yore got away with a lot. (Not that you're from 'yore' Heather!!!) I think they managed to slow us down quite a bit in our own writing development.
DeleteDon't have my writing in front of me, but that quote was tactile, real, and amazing. Great post!
ReplyDeleteYes, his writing is so good it makes me want to read his book, although I'm not usually a war novel reader.
Delete